| Date | Game | Result | Score | Notes |
|---|
| 12/8/2007 | Kentucky at (#15) Indiana | L | 51 - 70 | - |
| 12/9/2006 | Indiana at Kentucky | W | 59 - 54 | - |
| 12/10/2005 | (#15) Kentucky vs. (#18) Indiana | L | 53 - 79 | (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 12/11/2004 | (#10) Kentucky vs. Indiana | W | 73 - 58 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/20/2003 | (#2) Kentucky vs. Indiana | W | 80 - 41 | (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 12/21/2002 | (#16) Kentucky vs. (#6) Indiana | W | 70 - 64 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/22/2001 | (#7) Kentucky vs. Indiana | W | 66 - 52 | (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 12/22/2000 | Kentucky vs. Indiana | W | 88 - 74 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/4/1999 | (#13) Kentucky vs. (#23) Indiana | L | 75 - 83 | (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 12/8/1998 | (#8) Kentucky vs. (#11) Indiana | W | 70 - 61 OT | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/6/1997 | (#7) Kentucky vs. Indiana | W | 75 - 72 | (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 12/7/1996 | (#6) Kentucky vs. (#8) Indiana | W | 99 - 65 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/2/1995 | (#1) Kentucky vs. Indiana | W | 89 - 82 | (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 12/7/1994 | (#7) Kentucky vs. Indiana | W | 73 - 70 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/4/1993 | (#1) Kentucky vs. (#21) Indiana | L | 84 - 96 | (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 1/3/1993 | (#3) Kentucky vs. (#4) Indiana | W | 81 - 78 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/7/1991 | (#14) Kentucky vs. (#9) Indiana | W | 76 - 74 | (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 12/18/1990 | (#18) Kentucky at (#7) Indiana | L | 84 - 87 | - |
| 12/2/1989 | Kentucky vs. (#14) Indiana | L | 69 - 71 | Big Four Classic (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 12/20/1988 | Indiana at Kentucky | L | 52 - 75 | - |
| 12/5/1987 | (#2) Kentucky vs. (#5) Indiana | W | 82 - 76 OT | Big Four Classic (at Indianapolis, IN) |
| 12/6/1986 | (#13) Kentucky at (#3) Indiana | L | 66 - 71 | - |
| 12/7/1985 | (#19) Indiana at (#9) Kentucky | W | 63 - 58 | - |
| 12/8/1984 | Kentucky at (#11) Indiana | L | 68 - 81 | - |
| 12/3/1983 | Indiana at (#1) Kentucky | W | 59 - 54 | - |
| 3/24/1983 | (#12) Kentucky vs. (#5) Indiana | W | 64 - 59 | NCAA Mideast Regional (at Knoxville, TN) |
| 12/22/1982 | (#2) Kentucky at (#5) Indiana | L | 59 - 62 | - |
| 12/8/1981 | (#12) Indiana at (#2) Kentucky | W | 85 - 69 | - |
| 12/6/1980 | (#2) Kentucky at (#5) Indiana | W | 68 - 66 | - |
| 12/15/1979 | (#1) Indiana at (#5) Kentucky | W | 69 - 58 | - |
| 12/16/1978 | (#6) Kentucky at (#8) Indiana | L | 67 - 68 OT | - |
| 12/5/1977 | Indiana at (#1) Kentucky | W | 78 - 64 | - |
| 12/6/1976 | (#5) Kentucky at (#4) Indiana | W | 66 - 51 | - |
| 12/15/1975 | (#14) Kentucky vs. (#1) Indiana | L | 68 - 77 OT | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 3/22/1975 | (#5) Kentucky vs. (#1) Indiana | W | 92 - 90 | NCAA Mideast Regional (at Dayton, OH) |
| 12/7/1974 | (#15) Kentucky at (#3) Indiana | L | 74 - 98 | - |
| 12/8/1973 | (#10) Kentucky vs. (#3) Indiana | L | 68 - 77 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 3/17/1973 | (#17) Kentucky vs. (#6) Indiana | L | 65 - 72 | NCAA Mideast Regional (at Nashville, TN) |
| 12/9/1972 | (#8) Kentucky at Indiana | L | 58 - 64 | - |
| 12/11/1971 | (#7) Kentucky vs. Indiana | L | 89 - 90 2 OT | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/12/1970 | (#5) Kentucky at (#11) Indiana | W | 95 - 93 OT | - |
| 12/13/1969 | Indiana at (#1) Kentucky | W | 109 - 92 | - |
| 12/18/1965 | Indiana at Kentucky | W | 91 - 56 | UKIT Championship |
| 12/16/1944 | Kentucky vs. Indiana | W | 61 - 43 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/11/1943 | Kentucky vs. Indiana | W | 66 - 41 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/23/1942 | Kentucky vs. Indiana | L | 52 - 58 | (at Louisville, KY) |
| 12/30/1940 | Kentucky vs. Indiana | L | 45 - 48 | Sugar Bowl (at New Orleans, LA) |
| 2/4/1928 | Kentucky at Indiana | L | 29 - 48 | - |
| 12/21/1926 | Indiana at Kentucky | L | 19 - 38 | - |
| 1/5/1926 | Kentucky at Indiana | L | 23 - 34 | - |
| 12/18/1924 | Indiana at Kentucky | L | 18 - 20 | - |
