| Date | Opponent | Result | Score | Arena | Att. | Notes |
|---|
| 1/5/1935 | New York University | L | 22 - 23 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 16,539 | - |
| 1/8/1936 | New York University | L | 28 - 41 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,010 | - |
| 1/4/1939 | Long Island | L | 34 - 52 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 11,671 | - |
| 12/30/1943 | St. Johns | W | 44 - 38 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,179 | (at New York, NY) |
| 3/20/1944 | Utah | W | 46 - 38 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 16,273 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/22/1944 | St. Johns | L | 45 - 48 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,353 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/26/1944 | Oklahoma A&M | W | 45 - 29 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,374 | NIT [Consolation] (at New York, NY) |
| 1/1/1945 | Long Island | W | 62 - 52 OT | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 13,892 | - |
| 3/22/1945 | Ohio State | L | 37 - 45 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 15,584 | NCAA Eastern Regional First Round (at New York, NY) |
| 3/24/1945 | Tufts | W | 66 - 56 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,000 | NCAA Eastern Regional [Consolation] (at New York, NY) |
| 12/29/1945 | St. Johns | W | 73 - 59 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,411 | (at New York, NY) |
| 3/16/1946 | Arizona | W | 77 - 53 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,483 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/18/1946 | West Virginia | W | 59 - 51 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,478 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/20/1946 | Rhode Island | W | 46 - 45 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,475 | NIT Championship (at New York, NY) |
| 12/21/1946 | St. Johns | W | 70 - 50 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,493 | (at New York, NY) |
| 3/17/1947 | Long Island | W | 66 - 62 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,474 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/19/1947 | North Carolina State | W | 60 - 42 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,472 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/24/1947 | Utah | L | 45 - 49 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,493 | NIT Championship (at New York, NY) |
| 12/23/1947 | St. Johns | W | 52 - 40 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,423 | (at New York, NY) |
| 3/18/1948 | Columbia | W | 76 - 53 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,477 | NCAA Eastern Regional First Round (at New York, NY) |
| 3/20/1948 | Holy Cross | W | 60 - 52 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,472 | NCAA Eastern Regional Finals (at New York, NY) |
| 3/23/1948 | Baylor | W | 58 - 42 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 16,174 | NCAA Championship (at New York, NY) |
| 3/27/1948 | Louisville | W | 91 - 57 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 15,927 | Olympic Trials (at New York, NY) |
| 3/29/1948 | Baylor | W | 77 - 59 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 12,229 | Olympic Trials (at New York, NY) |
| 3/31/1948 | Phillips Oilers | L | 49 - 53 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,475 | Olympic Trials (at New York, NY) |
| 12/18/1948 | St. Johns | W | 57 - 30 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,451 | (at New York, NY) |
| 3/14/1949 | Loyola (Chicago) | L | 56 - 67 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 12,592 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/21/1949 | Villanova | W | 85 - 72 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,051 | NCAA Eastern Regional First Round (at New York, NY) |
| 3/22/1949 | Illinois | W | 76 - 47 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 15,126 | NCAA Eastern Regional Finals (at New York, NY) |
| 12/15/1949 | St. Johns | L | 58 - 69 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 17,000 | (at New York, NY) |
| 3/14/1950 | CCNY | L | 50 - 89 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,000 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 12/23/1950 | St. Johns | W | 43 - 37 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 18,332 | (at New York, NY) |
| 3/22/1951 | St. Johns | W | 59 - 43 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 14,214 | NCAA East Regional Semifinals (at New York, NY) |
| 3/24/1951 | Illinois | W | 76 - 74 | Madison Square Garden (Old) | 16,425 | NCAA East Regional Finals (at New York, NY) |
| 3/13/1976 | Niagara | W | 67 - 61 | Madison Square Garden | 7940 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/16/1976 | Kansas State | W | 81 - 78 | Madison Square Garden | 7632 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/18/1976 | Providence | W | 79 - 78 | Madison Square Garden | 11,444 | NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 3/21/1976 | UNC-Charlotte | W | 71 - 67 | Madison Square Garden | 12,415 | NIT Championship (at New York, NY) |
| 12/26/1981 | North Carolina | L | 69 - 82 | Brendan Byrne Arena | 18,116 | (at East Rutherford, NJ) |
| 12/28/1992 | Rutgers | W | 89 - 67 | Madison Square Garden | 14,110 | ECAC Holiday Festival (at New York, NY) |
| 12/30/1992 | St. Johns | W | 86 - 77 | Madison Square Garden | 14,856 | ECAC Holiday Festival (at New York, NY) |
| 2/6/1994 | Massachusetts | W | 67 - 64 | Brendan Byrne Arena | 18,489 | (at East Rutherford, NJ) |
| 12/27/1995 | Rider | W | 90 - 65 | Madison Square Garden | 13,175 | ECAC Holiday Festival (at New York, NY) |
| 12/29/1995 | Iona | W | 106 - 79 | Madison Square Garden | 13,659 | ECAC Holiday Festival (at New York, NY) |
| 3/30/1996 | Massachusetts | W | 81 - 74 | Continental Arena | 19,229 | NCAA Final Four (at East Rutherford, NJ) |
| 4/1/1996 | Syracuse | W | 76 - 67 | Continental Arena | 19,229 | NCAA Championship (at East Rutherford, NJ) |
| 12/22/1998 | Duke | L | 60 - 71 | Continental Arena | 20,029 | Jimmy V Classic (at East Rutherford, NJ) |
| 11/24/1999 | Maryland | W | 61 - 58 | Madison Square Garden | 10,762 | Preseason NIT (at New York, NY) |
| 11/26/1999 | Arizona | L | 51 - 63 | Madison Square Garden | 12,560 | Preseason NIT Championship (at New York, NY) |
| 11/9/2000 | St. Johns | L | 61 - 62 | Madison Square Garden | 16,415 | Coaches vs. Cancer IKON Classic (at New York, NY) |
| 11/10/2000 | UCLA | L | 92 - 97 OT | Madison Square Garden | 19,528 | Coaches vs. Cancer IKON Classic (at New York, NY) |
| 12/18/2001 | Duke | L | 92 - 95 OT | Continental Arena | 20,029 | Jimmy V Classic (at East Rutherford, NJ) |
| 12/9/2009 | Connecticut | W | 64 - 61 | Madison Square Garden | 15,874 | SEC/Big East Invitational (at New York, NY) |
| 3/25/2011 | Ohio State | W | 62 - 60 | Prudential Center | 18,343 | NCAA East Regional Semifinals (at Newark, NJ) |
| 3/27/2011 | North Carolina | W | 76 - 69 | Prudential Center | 18,278 | NCAA East Regional Finals (at Newark, NJ) |
| 11/15/2011 | Kansas | W | 75 - 65 | Madison Square Garden | 19,979 | Champions Classic (at New York, NY) |
| 11/9/2012 | Maryland | W | 72 - 69 | Barclays Center | 17,732 | Barclays Center Classic (at Brooklyn, NY) |
| 12/1/2013 | Providence | W | 79 - 65 | Barclays Center | 8086 | (at Brooklyn, NY) |
| 12/19/2015 | Ohio State | L | 67 - 74 | Barclays Center | 16,311 | CBS Sports Classic (at Brooklyn, NY) |
| 11/15/2016 | Michigan State | W | 69 - 48 | Madison Square Garden | 19,812 | Champions Classic (at New York, NY) |
| 12/11/2016 | Hofstra | W | 96 - 73 | Barclays Center | 7514 | Brooklyn Hoops Winter Festival (at Brooklyn, NY) |
| 12/9/2017 | Monmouth | W | 93 - 76 | Madison Square Garden | 10,438 | Citi Hoops Classic (at New York, NY) |
| 12/8/2018 | Seton Hall | L | 83 - 84 OT | Madison Square Garden | 10,244 | Citi Hoops Classic (at New York, NY) |
| 11/5/2019 | Michigan State | W | 69 - 62 | Madison Square Garden | 19,812 | Champions Classic (at New York, NY) |
| 11/9/2021 | Duke | L | 71 - 79 | Madison Square Garden | 18,132 | Champions Classic (at New York, NY) |
| 12/17/2022 | UCLA | L | 53 - 63 | Madison Square Garden | 20,261 | CBS Sports Classic (at New York, NY) |
