10 Players Chosen 12 Times.
Players chosen by the College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA). Teams typically consisted of five- or ten-players each.
| Name | Season | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Larry Conley | 1963-64 | 2nd |
| Louie Dampier | 1965-66 | - |
| Louie Dampier | 1966-67 | 1st |
| Dan Issel | 1969-70 | 1st |
| Mike Pratt | 1969-70 | - |
| Mike Casey | 1970-71 | 1st |
| Bob Guyette | 1973-74 | 2nd |
| Jimmy Dan Conner | 1974-75 | 1st |
| Bob Guyette | 1974-75 | 1st |
| Kyle Macy | 1978-79 | 1st |
| Chuck Verderber | 1980-81 | HM |
| Mark Pope | 1994-95 | 3rd |
